Data Management Skillbuilding Hub

Best Practice: Ensure basic quality control

BEST PRACTICE

Best Practices by Data Life Cycle




Ensure basic quality control

Data Life Cycle stage(s): Assure

Quality control practices are specific to the type of data being collected, but some generalities exist:

  • Data collected by instruments:
    • Values recorded by instruments should be checked to ensure they are within the sensible range of the instrument and the property being measured. Example: Concentrations cannot be < 0, and wind speed cannot exceed the maximum speed that the anemometer can record.
  • Analytical results:

    • Values measured in the laboratory should be checked to ensure that they are within the detection limit of the analytical method and are valid for what is being measured. If values are below the detection limit, they should be properly coded and qualified.
    • Any ancillary data used to assess data quality should be described and stored. Example: data used to compare instrument readings against known standards.
  • Observations (such as bird counts or plant cover):

    • Range checks and comparisons with historic maxima will help identify anomalous values that require further investigation.
    • Comparing current and past measurements help identify highly unlikely events. For example, it is unlikely that the girth of a tree will decrease from one year to the next.
  • Codes should be used to indicate quality of data:

    • Codes should be checked against the list of allowed values to validate code entries
    • When coded data are digitized, they should be re-checked against the original source. Double data entry, or having another person check and validate the data entered, is a good mechanism for identifying data entry errors.

Dates and times:

  • Ensure that dates and times are valid
  • Time zones should be clearly indicated (UTC or local)

Data Types:

  • Values should be consistent with the data type (integer, character, datetime) of the column in which they are entered. Example: 12-20-2000A should not be entered in a column of dates).
  • Use consistent data types in your data files. A database, for instance, will prevent entry of a string into a column identified as having integer data.

Geographic coordinates:

  • Map coordinates to detect errors

Description Rationale

Quality control procedures identify potential problems with data that could affect its use.

Additional Information:

Chapman, Arthur D. 2005. Principles of Data Quality, version 1.0. Report for the Global Biodiversity Information Facility, Copenhagen.

US Environmental Protection Agency. 2002. Guidance on Environmental Data Verification and Data Validation. http://www.epa.gov/quality/qs-docs/g8-final.pdf

Tags

 
 

Cite this best practice:

DataONE Best Practices Working Group, DataONE  (July 01, 2010) "Best Practice: Ensure basic quality control". Accessed through the Data Management Skillbuilding Hub at https://dataoneorg.github.io/Education/bestpractices/ensure-basic-quality on Aug 22, 2019


Home

Hosted by DataONE

In collaboration with the community, DataONE has developed high quality resources for helping educators and librarians with training in data management, including teaching materials, webinars and a database of best-practices to improve methods for data sharing and management.

Question If you have a question or concern, please open an Issue in this repository on GitHub.